This week I've chosen to discuss three picture books that I read for my Personal Reading Program.
Mirror written and illustrated by Jeannie Baker is a story told solely through the use of Baker’s amazing collage illustrations. This book compares a day in the life of two families. One family lives in Australia, the other in Morocco. Although both families reside in very different environments, their day-to-day life is very similar and interesting comparisons can be drawn. The lack of text means that this book could be suitable for a wide range of ages, with younger children focusing on drawing parallels between the lifestyles of the two families, whilst older children may try to add dialogue, infer meaning behind the situations and activities the families go through and question perceived differences between cultures.
The Troll written by Julia Donaldson and illustrated by David Roberts is a bizarre story that blends the old fairy tale of trolls living under bridges with a bunch of pirates looking for treasure. I did not particularly like this book. The resolution of the story was not clear enough to me, and lacked the finality that it aimed to achieve. The illustrations were far more interesting and informative than most of the text, and added depth to the rather shallow narrative, and although it created a more ‘fun’ element to the story; overall I found this book to be overrated. This book is best suited for 6 to 8 year olds.
This Is My Book written and illustrated by Mick Inkpen is an intesting read. The story revolves around a naughty dragon which eats letters from the text of the book whilst a brave mouse is tasked to retrieve them. Althoug the dialogue is rather simple, I really enjoyed the idea of interacting the actual grammar of the text with the audience. This is an excellent picture book for young readers and tackles punctuation and grammar in context with the narrative. The illustrations are also rather simple, but match well with the text. This books is best suited for children aged 5 to 7 who are learning about basic grammar rules.